Carborita70":nrue3qcb said:
Brad H - here are the numbers for both props with Slip calculated. Ken from prop gods was good enough to provide slip calcs for me, which I was ignorant of. He also suggested a 4 blade prop (Powertech OFS4R16 15 1/4 X 16) or adding cup to my existing 15 1/14 X 17 and he was not convinced the 19" prop I became so enamored with was the better choice. By the feel of how it blows out on turns, I can imagine the 19" blowing out frequently running in 3' sea. I can normally run no more than 25-30mph comfortably, I am looking for the best economy in this range, not top end speed. I will look more closely for the maker of the 19" prop, it is quite old a bit rusted and appears to have been worked on a bit. The 17" prop is made by Honda.
Sounds like you are on the right track with Ken. I am very interested to see the numbers with the 4bl. Lots of people have had good results working with him. I think stepping down in pitch and going to a 4blade is a good way to go.
From the PowerTech website on the OFS4-
15.25" DIAMETER, AVAILABLE IN 14"-28" IN PITCH, 4 BLADES, RIGHT- AND LEFT-HAND ROTATION, MODERATELY HIGH RAKE AND FULL TIP CUP FOR EXCELLENT LIFT AND GRIP, GOOD FOR SINGLE- AND TWIN-ENGINE OFFSHORE APPLICATIONS AND STERNDRIVES - POLISHED FINISH ONLY
Power Tech makes a decent prop. However, some of theirs are knock offs of other peoples wheels- Yam, Merc, Solas, etc. For example, the 3 blade SS PT I have is a really crappy knock off of a stock 3bl aluminum Yamaha wheel. They could have done so much with it by just thinning it out a little and actually using the increased strength of the SS compared to what they needed with Al. The thing sucks but I don't have the $$ to be playing with props the right way right now.
If the 19 was worked on, I doubt it's still a real 19. It may never have been a 19". Some of the stock Merc Bravo props are like this.
Also, adding cup to a prop sometimes makes it seem like it has more pitch. So the 16 he's proposing may act like an 17-18". Which is not a bad thing at all.
Do you have 46-5800 numbers for the 19" wheel? I was looking at slip too.
Big thing to remember with props and testing them...there is no substitute for going out and actually running the boat and finding out what works and taking notes on it. The pitch number stamped on it is not always accurate, and is really best used when comparing wheels of same make and model. Rake and cup are a lot harder to define, and not everybody does it the same way, or even knows how. What you get is an apparent or effective pitch that has been affected by both of these. #of blades and blade area has a lot to do with it too.